Free tool
Soft 404 Detector
See whether missing pages on a site return 200, and score a page for the signs of an error page served as OK.
How it works
What is the Soft 404 Detector?
The Soft 404 Detector is a free tool that checks whether a page looks like an error page that returns 200 OK. It requests your URL and a deliberately non-existent URL on the same host, reports how the site answers a missing page, and scores your page for error wording, thin text and similarity to that missing-page response.
How to use the Soft 404 Detector
- Enter the URL of the page you suspect, or any page on the site.
- Run the check. The tool also requests a made-up URL on the same host.
- Read how the site answers the made-up URL: a 404 or 410 is correct.
- Review the soft 404 score and the signs behind it for the page you entered.
What is a soft 404?
A soft 404 is a URL that tells visitors the page is missing, or shows almost nothing, while the server returns a success code such as 200. The status says the page is fine and the content says it is not. Search engines have to guess which one is true.
Google reports these in Search Console under the Soft 404 reason in the Page indexing report. Pages it classifies this way are not indexed.
How does the Soft 404 Detector work?
It makes two requests. The first is the URL you entered. The second is a random path in the same directory that cannot exist. If the made-up URL returns 200, directly or after a redirect to the home page, the site does not send real 404s, and every deleted page on it is a soft 404 candidate.
For the page you entered, the tool looks at three signs: error phrases such as not found in the title or H1, very little visible text, and how closely the text matches the response to the made-up URL, measured as the share of three-word phrases the two have in common.
How do I fix a soft 404?
Decide what the URL should be. If the page is gone and has no replacement, return 404 or 410. If it moved, redirect it with a 301 to the closest equivalent page, not to the home page, because Google can treat redirects to an unrelated page such as the home page as soft 404s too. If the page is real but thin, add the content that makes it worth indexing.
On the server side the usual cause is a custom error template that is rendered without setting the status code, or a single-page app that serves the same shell for every path.
What is a good soft 404 score?
The score runs from 0 to 100 and adds up the signs found: 50 for error wording in the title or H1, up to 40 for similarity to the missing-page response, up to 20 for thin text, and 10 if the site answers 200 for missing URLs. The tool calls 60 or more a likely soft 404 and 30 to 59 a possible one.
These weights are this tool's own rule of thumb, not Google's. Google uses its own classifier and does not publish it. A short but legitimate page can score 20, and that is fine.
Why does my missing page return 200?
Common causes are a catch-all route in a JavaScript framework, a CMS plugin that redirects every unknown URL to the home page, and a CDN or host configured to serve index.html for any path. Search result and filter pages with no results are another source: the template loads normally around an empty list.
Check the real status of any URL with the HTTP Status Checker, and find links pointing at dead pages with the Broken Link Checker.
Questions
- Is a soft 404 bad for SEO?
- It wastes crawling on pages that will not be indexed and can hide real problems, because error pages look healthy in status reports. Pages classified as soft 404 are left out of the index.
- What URL does the tool invent?
- A random path such as
/blog/spyc-missing-page-check-1a2b3c4d5e6fnext to the page you entered. It is requested once and nothing is submitted to the site. - Can the score be wrong?
- Yes. It is a heuristic. A page about the 404 status code, or a very short contact page, can score points without being an error page. Use it as a prompt to look.
- Should deleted pages return 404 or 410?
- Either works.
410states the removal is deliberate. Google treats the two almost identically, so use whichever your platform makes easier. - Is the Soft 404 Detector free?
- Yes, with a free spyc.ai account. Each run is limited only by the caps described on this page.
Technical SEO Tools
More in Technical SEO Tools
Opengraph Viewer
Paste a URL and see the card it produces when someone shares it — title, description, image.
View OpengraphOpen Graph Generator
Write the Open Graph tags, preview the card, copy the markup.
Generate Open Graph tagsRobots.txt Checker
Fetch any site's robots.txt and test one URL against it: allowed, or blocked by which rule.
View robots.txtReady when you are
Before your next buyer asks AI about you, ask AI about yourself
One check, four engines, about twenty seconds. We show you the answers before we ask for anything.